Infliction of injury offenses
are similarly defined in both civil and criminal courts. In
California, willful infliction of injury is a crime of domestic
violence in criminal court, and a cause of action in civil
court. In both instances, the charge applies to intimate partners.
In criminal law, intimate partners may be married, divorced,
living together or formerly living together, or have children
in common. Civil law includes partners who are or were dating.
Both courts recognize heterosexual couples and same-sex partnerships.
With respect to both civil and criminal law, an individual
is either guilty of the crime in criminal court or liable
for the cause of action in civil court if he or she willfully
injures an intimate partner. It doesn’t matter if the
alleged abuser barely touched the intimate partner.
A person charged with infliction of injury in criminal court may be charged with a felony, punishable by up to four years
in prison and a fine of up to $6,000. In civil court, a person
found liable for committing this cause of action will be subject
to heavy fines but cannot be sentenced to jail or prison.
The procedures involved in civil and criminal courts differ
with respect to infliction of injury. In a criminal case,
the prosecutor actually files the charge, not the victim.
In a civil case, the alleged victim (known as the plaintiff)
sues the alleged abuser (known as the defendant). It is much
easier to find the defendant liable in a civil suit because
the burden of proof required is lower. The judge or jury must
only believe that there is a “greater than 50 percent
chance” that the defendant caused the plaintiff’s
injury. In a criminal action, the burden of proof is higher
because the defendant’s freedom is at stake. The judge
or jury must find the defendant guilty “beyond a reasonable
doubt” before rendering a conviction.
In a civil infliction of injury lawsuit, three types of monetary
damages may be awarded to the plaintiff. General damages are
awarded to cover injuries that cannot be calculated to a specific
dollar amount. The most common type is pain and suffering
damages. Special damages are awarded to cover the plaintiff’s
out-of-pocket expenses. These expenses may include hospital
bills, replacement or repair costs for damages to personal
property, and reasonable attorney’s fees. Punitive damages
are awarded over and above special and general damages and
are intended to punish the defendant for engaging in willful
or malicious misconduct.
A person found liable for infliction of injury may have more
to worry about than just financial penalties. In addition,
a civil protective order may be issued against the defendant.
A civil protective order usually prohibits the restrained
individual from coming within a certain number of yards from
the protected party in order to prevent further abuse, including
threats or harassment. When a court believes that further
action is necessary to protect the plaintiff, the order may
be more restrictive. A civil protective order will expire
three years after being issued unless the court designates
a specific end date.
In both civil and criminal court, a person accused of infliction
of injury faces potentially life-changing consequences. Therefore,
it is crucial that an individual in this situation find a
lawyer immediately. The criminal defense attorneys at the
Kavinoky Law Firm have handled many types of California intimate
partner abuse cases and have successfully defended countless
individuals. They are adept at California domestic violence
law and can also offer first-rate referrals for civil defense
attorneys when needed. Contact a Kavinoky attorney today and
take an important step towards getting life back in order. |